diff --git a/P3D/Screens/MainMenu/PressStartScreen.vb b/P3D/Screens/MainMenu/PressStartScreen.vb
index 78a186453..691037805 100644
--- a/P3D/Screens/MainMenu/PressStartScreen.vb
+++ b/P3D/Screens/MainMenu/PressStartScreen.vb
@@ -596,11 +596,15 @@ Public Class NewMainMenuScreen
                                     ButtonResetSave()
                             End Select
                         End If
-                        If Controls.Dismiss(False, True, True) Then
+                        If Controls.Dismiss(False, True, False) Then
                             SoundManager.PlaySound("select")
                             DismissProfile()
                             _GameJoltButtonIndex = 0
                         End If
+                        If Controls.Dismiss(False, False, True) Then
+                            DismissProfile()
+                            _GameJoltButtonIndex = 0
+                        End If
                         ' Try to load the GameJolt profile once the player has logged in.
                         _MainProfiles(1).LoadGameJolt()
                     End If